Truthly

Reflections

Plato warned us about writing

The Church still put it to work. Now the tool is AI.

Zac Johnson, Cofounder, Truthly · November 13, 2026

In November 2026 I was in Rome for the third annual Builders AI Forum, a global Catholic gathering on artificial intelligence. Cardinal Michael Czerny gave the room a three-word invitation: “Let’s build together.”

The Church has been building for a long time. The author Thomas Woods puts it more strongly: “The Church, in fact, built Western civilization.”

She built it with tools that could do harm as well as good, so it should surprise no one that the same is true of AI. The Church’s habit has been to name the harm and use the tool with care. The first of those tools is one we no longer think of as a tool at all: writing.

Plato distrusted it. He argued that writing destroys memory and weakens the mind. The Jesuit scholar Walter Ong noticed that these are essentially the objections people make against computers — and that Plato made them in writing.

Writing is a technology, Ong said. It takes pens, inks, and prepared surfaces. It is entirely artificial, and it isolates the reader in a way speech never did. But he called it “the most momentous of all human technological inventions.” It changed how human beings think, and science, history, and philosophy could not have developed without it. Ong meant “artificial” as praise. “Like other artificial creations and indeed more than any other,” he wrote, “it is utterly invaluable.”

The first generations of Christians changed that technology. When serious literature still belonged on scrolls, they copied their Scriptures into the codex, the bound book. Eventually the rest of the world made the same switch.

The monks kept building. They put rivers to work, which let a man be at Vespers instead of at the millstone. Keeping their fixed hours of prayer helped give the West its habit of living by the clock. This discipline, developed so that men could pray on time, was later cut loose from prayer and used to run factories.

Italy’s first printing press was set up inside a Benedictine monastery. A German abbot wrote a treatise urging monks to keep copying by hand — and had it printed. The press did do harm. It turned Luther’s academic propositions into a movement. The historian Jacques Barzun called Gutenberg’s movable type “the physical instrument that tore the West asunder.” Catholics kept printing anyway. In 1938, St. Maximilian Kolbe’s monthly magazine peaked at about a million copies.

Fulton Sheen, beatified in September 2026, was on radio in 1930 and television in 1940, when very few Americans owned a set. In 1981 Mother Angelica started a television network in her monastery’s garage with two hundred dollars in the bank. Her rule: “Unless you are willing to do the ridiculous, God will not do the miraculous.”

The Vatican’s website went up on Christmas Day 1995, built by an American Franciscan sister. St. John Paul II said the Church approaches “this new medium with realism and confidence.” He went on: “The Internet can offer magnificent opportunities for evangelization if used with competence and a clear awareness of its strengths and weaknesses.”

Now the tool is artificial intelligence. Pope Leo XIV’s encyclical on it, Magnifica Humanitas, issues warnings and then sets people to work. Its central image is a construction site. “The primary choice,” he writes, “is not between a ‘yes’ or ‘no’ to technology, but rather between constructing Babel or rebuilding Jerusalem.” And he leaves no one out: “All are given their own section of the wall.”

A teenager in Milan had already started on his. St. Carlo Acutis taught himself to program and built a website about the world’s Eucharistic miracles. He also held himself to one hour of video games a week. His mother said he understood how harmful technology could be and wanted “to be the master of these means, not a slave.”

That is a builder. He knew the harm a tool could do, he set the limit, and he built. The Church has had people like him for two thousand years, and Pope Leo is asking for more.


Back to Blog

Try it for yourself.

Catholic AI built for you. Free to download.

Download Truthly — it's free

Stay Connected

Thoughtful reflections, stories, news, and updates from the team building Catholic AI.